TV'S SMALLPOX SCARE UNNERVES HEALTH OFFICIALS 



about Epidemiology & the department

Epidemiology academic information

Epidemiology faculty

Epidemilogy resources

sites of interest to Epidemiology professionals



Last Updated

13 Jul 2003

Source: Atlanta Journal-Constitution, May 16, 2002.

TV's smallpox scare unnerves health officials

By M.A.J. McKENNA . Atlanta Journal-Constitution Staff Writer

How can you tell when fear of bioterrorism has permeated pop culture? When it shows up as a plot line on "E.R."

A possible outbreak of smallpox is the centerpiece in tonight's season finale of the popular TV show (10 p.m. on NBC). The dramatic treatment of the fictional cases has disturbed national health authorities, who fear the panic portrayed in the cliffhanger episode could spill over into real life.

In the episode, according to an NBC synopsis, two children whose parents are Foreign Service officers arrive at the emergency room with fevers, are sent home after treatment, and return shortly afterward with pox-like eruptions covering their bodies. Havoc ensues: The hospital is quarantined and police guard the exits while restless patients begin a small riot in an attempt to escape.

Advance word of the episode caused enough concern at the National Association of City and County Health Officials and the Association of State and Territorial Health Officers -- two organizations whose members staff state, county and local health departments nationwide -- for the groups to issue briefing papers to reporters earlier this week.

Among the points stressed: Naturally occurring smallpox was eradicated in 1977; public health authorities are laying plans to counter a deliberate release of smallpox virus; people exposed to the virus can be protected even after the fact by vaccination.

If that seems an overreaction to a fictional scenario, consider this: A survey released last week by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that doctors and the public are poorly informed about smallpox, mistakenly believing that the virus is still circulating and that the vaccine against it, which can have dire side effects, is safe.

At the CDC, which has been inoculating and training smallpox-response teams since last fall, disease experts consulted informally with producers for "E.R." but have not seen the episode's script.

"I answered technical questions regarding smallpox and some other pox diseases and described some of the things we are doing to prepare, but I wasn't asked for approval of any scenarios," said Dr. Lisa Rotz, a member of the bioterrorism preparedness and response program.

Like the health department officials, the CDC is curious -- and a bit unnerved -- about the story line. A riot "isn't necessarily completely realistic," Rotz said. "We would ask: 'What would be the most prudent way to handle such a scenario?' But most likely a TV show that is a drama is going to select the most dramatic way."